Hollywood has been long at projecting other world cultures and communities on its screens. Regarding the Indian community, it hasn't been too pleasant- mostly stereotypical and clichéd- but it's been bunched up a notch or two for much more nuanced and authentic portrayals. These developments reflect a larger shift towards inclusion in international cinema, but it is far from enough that even Hollywood still needs to go a long way in how it portrays authenticity with this Indian community.
The Stereotype Era
For several decades, Hollywood-made films overly criticized the Indians and portrayed their culture through an extremely thin prism with certain cliched elements. Characters would be speaking with over-the-top accents, donning what they imagined to be traditional clothing while the scene hardly called for it, or performing Indian customs, which are literally but a small slice of the wealthy tapestry that is Indian culture.
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom or The Love Guru are movies that represent how this stereotype was playfully exploited, projecting the Indian identity as mysticism, the latter as poverty, or excessive religious practices. Such imagery was not only inexact but almost insulting because it helped romanticize stereotypes of Indians as a serpent charmer, gurus, or excessively spiritual beings.
One of the most enduring themes in Hollywood's depiction of Indians has been the "exotic mystic" paradigm. Movies, like Eat Pray Love, feature India as a place of spiritual enlightenment, as if the whole subcontinent were just a backdrop for Western characters' self-discovery. While this idea of India is true in small, specific ways, it neglects to speak of the vibrancy and complexity of the nation.
Westernization of Indian Culture
Portraying Indians Westernized also makes the characters palatable. The translation of this ends up as Indians speaking better English and living in upscale urban centres or ignoring their cultural heritage. Films such as The Namesake do a better job of highlighting the cultural conflict second-generation immigrants face. However, most Hollywood productions continue to advance the notion of "authentic" Indians as those who live within the cultural parameters relating to language, food, and rituals and portray little of the diversity central to the Indian experience.
The Recent Push for Authenticity
For the past few decades, Hollywood has made some steps toward a realistic portrayal of Indian characters and stories. Despite the criticism of the way Slumdog Millionaire portrayed Indian poverty, still, it did bring much more depth into the Indian characters and brought global exposure to Indian talent. Movies like Lion would expose audiences to a raw look at the struggles of an Indian boy separated from his family and represent India through the eyes of a more realistic lens. Increasing numbers of Indian actors are taking roles that didn’t map onto the stereotypical or marginal type.
Figures such as Priyanka Chopra Jonas, who appeared in Baywatch and Quantico, and Mindy Kaling, whose work was in The Mindy Project, represent more diverse and complex representations of Indians. These types of roles establish Indians as professionals, complex characters with their ambitions, identities, and lives, and do not find their meaning solely based on their ethnicity.
Indian Film Makers and Actors in Hollywood
Indian filmmakers and writers, in their rising presence, are contributing to a more respectful representation. Directors like Mira Nair and M. Night Shyamalan have been part of Hollywood, though, writers and directors of Indian origin have started telling stories that blend West and Indian sensibilities without sacrificing authenticity. They are making characters that are true to the experiences of Indian people. Whether immigrants or natives, they reveal the diversity of Indian identities.
A Need for Greater Cultural Nuance
Despite such strides, Hollywood remains open to improvement. Indian culture cannot be monolithic; it cuts across a multiplicity of religions, languages, and traditions. In such a scenario, Hollywood needs to know that to portray an Indian character is not just about selecting the accent or as a backdrop for the setting of a story in India. It's about capturing a diversity of complexity emanating from a lived life, the struggle and success of a global community that cannot be pigeonholed into a few stock characteristics.
Conclusion
The portrayal of the Indian community in Hollywood is slowly progressing from simplistic stereotypes to more complex, intricately depicted characters. While there is a demand among global audiences for better and more meaningful stories that bring out real diversity, the expectations for Hollywood to do justice to the Indian community by portraying it with depth, accuracy, and respect in the same manner are increasing. No doubt, for this change, the time has finally come when Indian characters are viewed and not taken as a trope but as genuine, relatable, and multidimensional characters. It would hence enhance Hollywood and resonate with audience power across the globe, seeking stories that reflect the world they live in.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments below. If you have burning thoughts or opinions to express, please feel free to reach out to us at larra@globalindiannetwork.com.
