The Impact of Brain Drain in India on Innovation and Economic Growth

Merriam-Webster defines brain drain as the “departure of educated or professional people from one country, economic sector, or field for another, usually for better pay or living conditions.” Brain drain occurs when highly skilled workers or students looking for better education opportunities emigrate to developed countries to seek better opportunities than what is available in their home country.

These individuals are usually doctors, engineers, IT professionals, and other experts, along with students who go abroad in pursuit of a better standard of living, higher wages, and augmented career prospects. The impact of brain drain in India is both negative and positive for India’s development and global standing regarding its innovation and economic growth.

What are the Main Reasons for Brain Drain in India?

• Higher education abroad: The lack of adequate investment in India’s higher education makes moving to foreign universities an attractive prospect. The success of work visa programs and numerous scholarships provided to international students and graduates are contributing factors.
• Lack of employment opportunities: As India is the most populous country in the world, the job market is inevitably very competitive. As a result, salaries are forced to come down significantly as more and more people are willing to work for lower wages. The search for higher pay and employment opportunities induces people to move abroad for lucrative businesses. 
• Better quality of life: India, a third-world country, is unable to provide a quality standard of living to all sections of society. More employment, a better environment, and healthcare abroad ensure a better quality of life, which is a major factor in the brain drain.
• Taxation policy: The high tax rate and complexity of the regulatory regime in India are another cause of brain drain. Insufficient wages and high tax rates create a paradoxical cycle, and individuals and families cannot cope with it, so they find it better to move to other countries. 

What is the Impact of Brain Drain in India?

Positive Impacts

While brain drain mainly has disadvantages, it can also have some positive impacts in India.

• Remittances: Also known as brain gain, remittances occur when students studying abroad return to their home country with high skills and expertise and continue working in India. Their increased productivity gives rise to increased economic growth. 
• Global exposure: In this rapidly progressing economy, it is crucial to have a high skill set, and enhanced global exposure helps with this. When you are aware of how businesses work in foreign countries, the exposure gives you an edge to perform better in your home country. 
• Diaspora contribution: The Indian diaspora has played a significant role in advocating for India on the global stage, fostering trade relations, and supporting various initiatives. Every country in the world has an Indian as its citizen, thereby greatly increasing the recognition of Indians worldwide.

Negative Impacts

The outflow of skilled individuals benefits the host countries but brings several challenges for India, including loss of talent and economic impact, both of which are negative impacts of brain drain in India.

• Economic disparity: Despite remittances, the emigration of highly skilled workers can lead to economic disparities and hinder India’s progress. Due to unequal skills and wages, huge disparities hinder progress because many might view it as unfair and leave the company for other opportunities suited to their skill levels.
• Skills gap: The training and education provided in India differ vastly from what is provided abroad, creating a skills gap between people who study in India and those who study abroad. While India is mainly focused on theory, foreign countries encourage a practical approach, which is more beneficial in the long run. Therefore, this skills gap ends up affecting the country’s growth and development. 
• Reduction in innovation, research, and development: This is particularly true in developing countries like India, where a lack of resources may drive talented individuals to seek better prospects elsewhere. Brain drain can disrupt existing research networks and collaborations, making it more difficult for researchers to share ideas, resources, and findings.
• Loss of revenue: Governments rely on income taxes to fund their social programs and infrastructure projects. A mass exodus leads to a drop in tax receipts, inhibiting economic growth and development. This mass exodus not only reduces the revenue created but also reduces the source of revenue to balance out its loss. With professionals exiting the labour market in India, productivity decreases, thus decreasing revenue.
• Healthcare challenges: In search of better wages, doctors also prefer to move to areas that provide better pay, as healthcare in India is fairly cheaper in comparison to more developed countries. While this is an advantage for patients, it is not so much for the doctors. Their leaving the country greatly impacts the healthcare situation in India, especially in the rural parts.

Solutions to Tackle Brain Drain

Following are some of the solutions to reduce the negative impact of brain drain in India:

• Improving opportunities: More opportunities need to be created, and working conditions need to be enhanced to ensure job security. Further, competitive wages should be offered, encouraging people to stay and give back to India.
• Investing in education: One major reason for the brain drain is that students pursuing higher studies go to major colleges abroad, such as the Ivy Leagues, for better facilities. Therefore, more investment and resources should go to education and foreign institutes in India, as well as skill development.
• Attractive policies: Research grants and incentives for entrepreneurship should be provided. A favourable taxation policy for entrepreneurs can help reduce the brain drain and create jobs. The government can reduce the tax burden on startups and provide tax breaks for businesses that invest in research and development.
• Economic growth: Making economic investments to boost growth often provides incentives for people to stay because it means access to better and more resources, personal economic prosperity, and the potential for a higher standard of living.

RELATED READING: Brain Drain: The Great Indian Problem

Conclusion

According to the International Migration 2020 Highlights report, India topped the list of countries with the largest diasporas in 2020, with 18 million persons from India living outside the country of birth. Every year, 2.5 million Indians migrate overseas, which is a testament to the huge negative impact of brain drain in India.

As India struggles to retain its intellectual capital against the lure of better prospects in first-world countries, it is crucial to strike a balance between retaining talent and allowing individuals to pursue global opportunities while keeping India’s economic growth and innovation in mind.

FAQs